What do guys really think about women who sleep with them on the first date? Do men think women can be trusted not to cheat? Ex-Survivor finalist Colby Donaldson gives women answers to these and other burning questions when he and his buddies get together for a pow-wow.

• Hear the boys dish on what they really look for in a woman.

• Colby and the guys discuss hot-button topics like cheating, and how they've learned to answer the dreaded question: "Does my butt look big in this?"
  Their answers might surprise you!

Although the guys revealed a lot during their pow-wow, Rachael has a few more questions while she's got Colby in the hot seat at her kitchen table. "Is there a rule on how long a guy waits before calling a girl after the first date, if you like her? Is there a secret-guy club rule on how long he waits?"

"All four of us disagreed," says Colby. "First of all, there should be a call. Obviously text message, e-mail, they're all a way to communicate, but they lack all the personal value that a phone call has. A laugh, or when you can hear a smile on the phone, you know that means something. So I think definitely stay away from the text messages and e-mails. As far as how long you wait, if you're into the woman, call her. I'm not waiting a day, two days ... to me that all falls under game play. Games are for kids. As adults, you don't need it."

What about the subject of younger guys dating older women? Or, older women with kids?

"This was another issue that was kind of split right down the middle," Colby explains. "To me, it's not an issue and I know a lot of men out there that feel the same way. Why would you shut off that entire group of women? It's like saying I don't date brunettes or blondes, or whatever. Why close that door before you ever give them the opportunity, this could be the woman of your dreams. A lot of times, it's a guy who has kids, and what if she said no to you just based on the fact that you already had children? The truth is it's still split down the middle."